To replace Ben or to replace Bruce? Who should be Batman moving forward in the DC Cinematic Universe?

Now that the dust from Justice League has settled, we can start to look to the future of the DC Cinematic Universe. Perhaps the biggest question about the future is who will be Batman going forth. It has been the worst kept secret that Ben Affleck wants out of the cowl, with Affleck even telling USA Today:

The new Batman movie being developed by Matt Reeves (War for the Planet of the Apes) is “something I’m contemplating,” says Affleck, who originally was tapped to direct. “You don’t do it forever, so I want to find a graceful and cool way to segue out of it.”

But what hadn’t been revealed is would he be Batman in a post Justice League world. I believe given the negative reception to Justice League (it’s poor box office performance, low critic scores and the fan backlash) it is all but guaranteed that that was the last time Ben Affleck would portray the Dark Knight. Though rather than focus on the past, let us look to the future and answer the question; should Warner Brothers replace Ben Affleck as Batman or replace the character of Bruce Wayne as Batman?

Affleck2
Image via Warner Brothers

Ben Affleck has been my favourite Batman. I think he gets a deeper layer to Batman that has not been seen in any other performance. Something he does differently is the idea that Bruce Wayne died in the ally with his parents and the Batman was born. Ben Affleck treats Bruce Wayne as the alter ego, perhaps seen best in his scene at Luther’s party where he comments on Mercy Graves shoes. The comment comes off as out of character, because it is. He is trying to cover the fact he is doing something covert by looking somewhat incompetent. Even the way he deals with Batman’s physicality and brutality highlights that he understands that for someone to dress up as a bat to beat up criminals they must be “out of your mind”,to quote Aquaman. The development of the character of Batman has come a long way since the 60’s TV show. Whilst I don’t love every aspect of Affleck’s Batman, the fact that he kills, or as Zack Snyder puts it ‘commits Manslaughter’, there was so much good in this character that I was looking forward to seeing Ben Affleck direct, write and star in many more Batman movies. Unfortunately, what I want and what might happen are two very different things. So with Ben looking to segue out of the role, we come back to the question, do you replace the actor or the character?

Affleck5
Image via Warner Brothers

In comic books it is not uncommon to find different characters taking up the mantle of heroes, though this isn’t something that is known to the general public. This is seen in particular with Robin, with multiple people being a sidekick to Batman after the previous Robin moved on. In fact while most people would know that Robin is Batman’s sidekick, they couldn’t name any of the characters that have been the Boy Wonder. With the character of Batman though, everyone knows that Bruce Wayne is Batman and Batman is Bruce Wayne. You could ask 100 people to name the alter ego of Batman and the majority would say Bruce Wayne, with many of them not even thinking another character has taken up the mantle of the Dark Knight in the comics. There has been some comments online from film and comic book pundits saying the easiest way forward for the character of Batman is to replace Bruce Wayne, have Ben Affleck walk away as Bruce and have another actor come and play Dick Grayson (the first Robin and Nightwing) who would become The Batman. Personally, I don’t like this idea; Batman is one of, if not the biggest comic book character with hard-core fans and general audiences knowing him from one of his many iterations in film, television, animation, comics and video games. But for the large majority of fans, they know Batman as Bruce Wayne, and even fewer fans actually know Dick Grayson was the first Robin and is currently Nightwing. This is seen in the atrocious final moments of The Dark Knight Rises, when Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s character John Blake was told to use his real name, Robin. Rather than say his real name was Dick Grayson, Jason Todd, Tim Drake or even say his real name is Damien (Damien Wayne, son of Bruce and Talia Al Ghul), which would have been a great nod to fans, they went with his real name is Robin. So no, having Dick Grayson become Batman wouldn’t work for general audience, and after the disappointing result of Justice League, that is who WB and DC need to win over.

JGL
Image via Warner Brothers

‘But what about Flashpoint’ I hear the comic book readers yell, an alternate reality where Bruce dies and his father Thomas Wayne became the Batman. I’ll be the first to admit that seeing Jeffery Dean Morgan as Batman would be awesome but then you have to look at the larger ramifications of Flashpoint. Flashpoint isn’t as simple as resetting the universe, because as we saw on the CW The Flash, even when you escape Flashpoint some of the Universe may change but a lot will be the same. Having Thomas Wayne as Batman in Flashpoint makes sense, but when we return to the normal time line, it would be Bruce that is Batman again. Warner Brothers can’t think short term, or just focus on event movies, they won’t survive if they do.

FLashpoint
Image via DC Animation

So, if you don’t replace Bruce Wayne, and your current actor wants to segue out of the role what do you do? Well you replace the actor and bring in someone new to play Bruce Wayne and The Batman. I am not going to go through the list of actors who could play Batman, because one: that would be a long list and two: the speculation wouldn’t help. Replacing an actor is easier than is sounds, just look at Spider-Man, we have had 3 different versions of Peter Parker in the past 15 years, and the audience was able to embrace the change each time. We have seen the recasting of Professor X and Magneto from two actors born to play those roles in Sir Patrick Stewart and Sir Ian McKellen to James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender. Again, the audience embraced it. These weren’t cinematic universes though, so what about the continuity? For this answer look no further than the Marvel Cinematic Universe. In the first Iron Man film, Terrance Howard was cast as James Rhodes aka War Machine but in Iron Man 2 he was replace by Don Cheadle and no one batted an eye. The biggest recasting was when Edward Norton pulled out of playing Bruce Banner, aka Hulk, in The Avengers. Norton was Banner in 2008s The Incredible Hulk and was replace in 2012s The Avengers by Mark Ruffalo. Ruffalo even mentions his involvement in the events of The Incredible Hulk, saying last time he was in New York he sort of broke Harlem. Just a subtle nod that he is still the same character from the previous movie, despite being a different actor.

Affleck3
Image via Warner Brothers

Now that you have replace Ben Affleck and you have found your new Bruce Wayne, (for arguments sake Jake Gyllenhaal, who is tipped to be Matt Reeve’s top choice) what do you do? The answer is simple: you do nothing different. You have Clark and Diana say, “we need Bruce.” They show up to Wayne Manor or the Batcave and see Jeremy Irons as Alfred and Jake Gyllennhaal as Bruce and say “Hi Bruce we need your help.” Or something along those lines, just with much better dialogue. This shows that the story will continue but with a different actor as Batman, while we still get Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman and the other fan favourites.

Affleck1
Image via IMDb

Don’t forget to subscribe to stay up to date with everything happening with Millennial Movies. Just put your email in the box below to subscribe. You can also find me on FacebookTwitter, and Instagram.

 

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

 

 

8 thoughts on “To replace Ben or to replace Bruce? Who should be Batman moving forward in the DC Cinematic Universe?

Add yours

  1. An interesting piece. Personally, I like Ben as Batman. In the of who you’d replace though, I would honestly rather they switch it to Dick. I really enjoyed Battle for the Cowl, and loved the way Dick’s Batman played off Damien’s Robin. Bruce Wayne actually bores me as a character a lot of the time, so a switch like that would suit me fine.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think for comic book fans the switch would be ok because they know who the characters are. I feel that unfortunately the Cinematic Universe hasn’t done enough to earn the right to have Dick Grayson become Batman. Seeing Dick and Damien on the big screen would be awesome though.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. If Affleck was Batman for say 6 movies and we got to know the Bat family really well it could work. We could potentially see a Red Hood scenario and for Afflecks final film you do something along the lines of Knightfall, earning the right to have Bruce step away.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Interesting question that doesn’t really have a very easy answer either. I agre that Ben Affleck has played an absolutely amazing role so far and is a better Batman than I ever would have imagined ( I still favor Christian Bale though). That said, for me Bruce Wayne is Batman. I’m not that well informed in the DC universe, so I honestly don;t see another character as Batman. I think it’s true for most of the general moviegoing audience. Batman has been played by so many different actors now, just as for instance James Bond, that I don’t see a problem with another actor taking on the role though 😀
    Great post, especially like the cool insights for a couple of the other characters that could play Batman 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I love that you brought up James Bond. It’s funny how we don’t think about how many times that actor has changed. I ultimately think that they will just recast Affleck and continue, something I am a little disappointed with.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: